What’s it about: Inside a cluster of fused together derelict
spaceships, for the Doctor’s oldest friends, and one of his newest ones are
lost and confused. They don’t know how they got there or what they’re meant to
be doing but as the place is infested with Daleks, Sontarans and dinosaurs
their first priority is staying alive. To their collective relief the Doctor
shows up and has a reasonable idea of what’s going on. If the six of them work
together they can escape this place and get home. But, unexpectedly, others may
be working together to ensure that they all die here…
An English Gentleman: The Doctor is literally overjoyed to
be reunited with his old friends Chesterton and Steven – it’s a far cry from
his usual despondent attitude with Tegan! I had to stifle a giggle when Ian and
Steven comment that they are too old for this gig and take the opportunity to
ask why the Doctor looks so young these days! You forget that sixties Who was a
time before regeneration and Time Lords (Steven says with some shock ‘your
people?’ as though he had never considered the possibility of bring more than
one being like the Doctor) and the Doctor economically skips over the
explanations (‘my people change when their bodies wear out…’). He’s never
seriously considered doing anything else but travelling. Suddenly having all of
these wonderful friends back again means that he doesn’t want to let any of
them go. Waving a gun around rarely helps in the Doctor’s experience, it merely
gives people more of a reason to shoot. The Doctor admits he would love to see
Barbara and all of them again one day and promises to pop in on all of them.
Science Teacher: The thought of Ian Chesterton and Steven
Taylor meeting up so many years after The Chase (in the characters own lives and
in our time so long after the transmission of the 1965 classic) is a delight
and I love how they laugh heartily at how much they have both changed since
they last saw each other. He keeps thinking that the only time he has ever
encountered anything as weird as this was when he was with the Doctor so he
must be involved somehow. He’s supposed to be retired but he got bored with it
and has gone back to teaching. Barbara keeps saying that he should take it easy
but she is still working on a new book so you can’t talk! I have a secret love
(well not so secret as I keep harping on about it!) for The Chase simply
because it commits so many cardinal sins against drama and television in
general and it has become one of my guilty pleasures so to have a re-run of the
‘Ooh-ooh! Archie!’ scene made me squeal with delight! ‘Oi Fred!’ ‘I think it’s
a female…’ ‘Oi Freda!’ Hahaha! His nature dictates that he stays alive and gets
back to his wife.
Alien Orphan: Nyssa sounds almost tentative when she says
that she is fond of the Doctor and that they work well together. Its not in the
script but a little something added by Sarah Sutton almost to suggest that
there is something to hide about her feeling towards the Doctor. Ian is
impressed with her because he never met anyone who came anywhere near his
scientific level. She wonders wistfully that perhaps she should never have left
him.
Aggressive Astronaut: Steven admits that he left the Doctor
a long time ago so this s the first audio from Big Finish to be set after The
Savages and our first chance to catch up with the characters since his decision
to become the ruler of a planet. Its rather wonderful that he and Ian met up in
a story featuring Daleks so there are no need for explanations for either of
them. Steven recognises the Sontarans from a Servo Unit that landed ‘back home’
a few years ago and he understands their probic vent weakness. He wondered if
the Doctor might have popped back to see how he was getting along but it never
happened and he gets the opportunity now to apologise for failing to do so.
Steven still thinks he was little more than a kid when he left the Doctor and
that he didn’t quite know what he was letting himself in for. There is peace,
more or less, and the Doctor tells him he has done good work. For Steven seeing
Sara again is the most wonderful surprise. Her death weighed heavily on him (so
much so it was the catalyst for him to almost leave the Doctor) and there was
clearly more than just a little affection between them by the time she was age
to death.
The Duchess: ‘When we parted company it all seemed rather
rushed…’ Theirs is something of a Highlanders vibe when Polly teams up with
Sara Kingdom and they tackle a deadly dinosaur together (although Sara is far
more kick ass than the snivelling Kirsty!). As ever Polly’s attire is more
about looking drop dead gorgeous than practicality (at least this time she was
going to a restaurant!) and Sara thought her terrifyingly pointed high heels
were weapons! Polly offers to make some tea (but of course she does!) when the
technical know-how is lost on her. The Doctor questions whether that was all
she thought she ever did and reminds her that she took down a guard detail of
Cybermen once! Perhaps she wasn’t always the bravest person he had ever
travelled with but she had a fierce sense of what was right or wrong and the
Doctor can still remember he standing up to the Cyberleader and demanding to
know why he didn’t care. What he said was logical but what she said was right.
She was an inspiration to him and has been ever since. Turns out she did get
together with Ben in the end and she starts to tell the story of her fathers
horrified reaction when she brought him home the first time. Ian and Barbara
& Ben and Polly – two friendships that developed into something more and
that feels right to me. In both cases they were made for each other. In a
moment of empowerment for Polly she uses her stiletto heel to stab a Sontaran
in the probic vent and saves the Doctor’s life.
SSS: Sara Kingdom manages to take out a squadron of Daleks
without breaking a sweat much to Polly’s delight.
Standout Performance: Nearly an impossible section to
comment in considering this is an assembly of some of Big Finish’s finest
performers from the companion chronicles range. There’s Anneke Wills who still
manages to inject a great deal of spunk and fire into Polly, Jean Marsh who
adds an extra touch of elegance to the story with her portrayal of Sara
Kingdom, Peter Purves who has never let me down be it on television or audio
and remains to this day one of my favourite companions as Steven Taylor and
Sarah Sutton who is massively underrated in fan circles and deserves a great
deal of respect for her continuing support of the audios and development of her
character. However any audio that features the mighty William Russell as Ian as
automatically raised from good to great, he’s a phenomenon in his own right and
as glorious here as every one of his turns in the companion chronicles.
Marvellous companions, all of them.
Sparkling Dialogue: ‘The Doctor is running away!’ – very
funny coming from a Dalek!
‘You know I’ve always believed that you can’t solve peoples
problems forever. All you can do is try to solve today’s!’
‘Sometimes its too easy to keep on going forward. Perhaps
sometimes I should give myself the luxury of looking back to appreciate all the
good people I’ve left behind.’
Great Ideas: At first I wondered how writer Eddie Robson was
going to get away with including five companions, Daleks, Sontarans and
dinosaurs without this feeling like the ultimate piece of fanwank when it came
to me that this was an homage to The Five Doctors and it had to be set on the
Death Zone of Gallifrey! Yes that’s right…it took me time to figure that
one out! The clue was even in the title! When I first heard of the Cube-like
premise (bringing five of the Doctor’s assistants together in an unknown
location for a dark purpose) of The Five Companions I figured the opening scene
would be of two companions meeting and asking lots of questions so imagine my
delight when Robson delays that and has Steven meet a confused Dalek in the
first scene! If these special freebie releases aren’t about making all our
dreams come true then I don’t know what is and listening to Ian and Steven
battling one of the new series Daleks is an absolute joy on the ear. It crosses
the boundaries from classic (about as classic as you can get) and new Who in a
way that will appal anally retentive fans and delight the rest of us. Its only
when you realise who the assembled guest companions are that you realise these
are the lucky ones that were immersed in the Dalekmania of the sixties and
featured in some of their best ever stories (it doesn’t come much better than
The Daleks, The Daleks’ Masterplan and Power of the Daleks!). Much like the
giddy joy of Doomsday this story features the coming together of the Daleks and
another of the Doctor’s greatest foes (for me the Sontarans are far more
interesting than the Cybermen but that’s much of a muchness) and the Sontaran
Commander states that the Daleks have always underestimated the Sontaran race
and that they fought a rear guard action against a Dalek attack whilst fighting
the Rutan in the Madelon Cluster (ooh…can we possibly have that story realised
please?). They enjoy a delicious bitch fight where the Sontarans boast that
they almost conquered Gallifrey and the Daleks whine that they concentrate too
much on honour to get anything done! Nyssa describes the Death Zone as a pocket
dimension, an artifical construct with no way back into the real universe. All
of the Doctor’s companions admit that there isn’t a day when they don’t think
about him.
Audio Landscape: Footsteps, a Dalek swivelling on its base,
echoey voices, a creaking hull, terrifying roaring dinosaurs, banging against
the bulkhead, dripping water, blasters, Sontaran communications device (it
sounds just like the one from The Time Warrior!), Dalek screams, extermination
blasts, Sontarans screaming as they battle each other in practice, wind
whipping through the ship trying to claw the Doctor’s friends into the vacuum
of space.
Standout Scene: The entire release is one long standout
scene.
Result: I can’t imagine this failing to hit the spot of any
Doctor Who fan. Firstly you have the glorious idea of a Five Doctors style
homage then the initial delight of having all of the assembled companions
coming together and finally there is the fanboy dream of trying to fit all of the
continuity together like a Doctor Who jigsaw and figuring out at what point in
their lives we are meeting them all. Like The Five Doctors this is less about
telling a good story and more about nostalgia and popcorn entertainment but as
a celebratory pat on the back at the wealth of history this show has amassed
The Five Companions is not only hugely enjoyable but also necessary. The show
needs to acknowledge its history every once and a while and if it can be as
ridiculously entertaining as this then so much the better! Every scene is
packed full of goodies, gorgeous observations and kisses to the past. What
really shocked me was how well these companions worked together and by the end
of the story I was wishing we could embark on some kind of ensemble show that
allowed them to continue to operate this effectively together! A deliriously
enjoyable one off: 9/10
After "The Plague Entropy" is difficult to hear this story. Would it have been better to use Vicki or Zoe instead of Nyssa?
ReplyDeleteAnd this story contradicts "1963: Fanfare for the Common Men" and "The Toy" as both show the Doctor talk to Nyssa about Susan.
Wait a sec. I realized I am several years behind, but I've just had a chance to listen to this.
ReplyDeleteI agree with everything you said, Joe, but I'm left wondering...
Did they ever determine *who* transported them all to the Death Zone? The Doctor mentions at one point that the Master would be crazy enough to do it, but did they ever actually answer that question, and I just missed it?
I'll probably end up listening to this whole thing again, just to double-check, but, as of right now, it is driving me crazy.
(Doesn't mean I didn't love this. Right at the top of my favorite Big Finish stories. :) )