Here He Comes in a Great Big Tractor: Well where has John
Barrowman been hiding these acting skills? Aside from a few moments of near
Shakespearean drama, there was always a sense that Barrowman was performing
rather than acting. Something of the showman in him. Which made him perfect for
Torchwood because it showcased every extreme imaginable. Sometimes the TV
wasn't big enough to contain the ambition of the writers and the Barrowman's
ego working in tandem. Audio is a very different beast, there's no chance to
strut about, showing off your physique or portraying every line as though you
are about to break into song. It's a contained medium, one where the story and
characterisation comes first. And Barrowman absolutely aces it. He's focused
and committed, he's left his showmanship at the door and he's delivering a rock
solid performance.
Jack has been keeping an eye on George Wilson for some time
and now he has appeared in Cardiff it was time to catch up with him. Torchwood
keeps tabs on all of the conspiracy nuts, no matter how far fetched their
theories are because one of them might be privileged to know the truth about
extraterrestrials in some cases. I love the fact that Jack expects Torchwood to
be this secret organisation and yet they drive around Cardiff in a black four wheeled
drive with flashing blue lights that advertises their presence to all and
sundry. Maybe he needs to re-read the definition of covert in the dictionary.
He's happy to threaten people and pull strings if they come close to exposing
the organisation. The idea of Jac being immortal was one of the best ideas that
Davies ever came up with because it allowed the production team to torture the
character in varied and spectacular ways (I think my favourite is still him
being blown to pieces in the first episode of Children of Earth but for sheer
nastiness the people lining up to take a slice out of him in Miracle Day's
Immortal Sins has to take the vote) and it looks like the production tea behind
the audios are going to keep up the torment. The Conspiracy features a gruesome
moment where Jack is shot in the head unexpectedly. How can you not feel for
him after that?
Standout Performance: What this story needed was a stand up
performance from whoever played Wilson because his paranoid personality and
wild theories are the sort of characterisation it would be very easy to send
up. Or at least make a mockery out of whilst trying to ground him in reality.
What a coup to score John Sessions then, who does no such thing. He plays the
part as if he believes every single word that comes out of Wilson's mouth.
There is a conviction there that comes from an actor that is one hundred
percent committed to bringing this man to life with as much integrity as
possible. I was really impressed, especially when the truth about his character
is revealed.
Sparkling Dialogue: 'We've learned one very important thing
about humanity. They love a lie.'
Great Ideas: Who are the Committee and where do they come
from? Very good questions but it would appear they are in control of peoples
lives globally in the shadows and the population doesn't have a clue about it.
The powers that be want us to believe that we are all separate,
self-controlling entities and that is where most of the worlds problems stem
from - these might be the words of a conspiracy nut (albeit one who is privy to
some very real facts) but anybody with a semblance of sense knows that their
lives are governed to a certain degree. The Committee are the puppet masters,
the ones who have been running the show behind the scenes throughout human
history. For hundreds, maybe even thousands of years. Was the narrative of the
wars throughout history all a fiction? Were they all orchestrated by the
Committee? Wars that were caused merely as a catalyst to give human beings the
technology to systematically annihilate each other, or at least to keep the
population under control. Doctor Who has played about with the idea of aliens
having significant input into the progress of humanity for diverse purposes
(the Daemons, the Jaggaroth) but this is the first time that it feels truly
insidious, like we are being directed towards a dark purpose. The Enablers are
the ones working in intelligence agencies and law enforcement, they are the
Committee members amongst the people ensuring that events go according to plan.
Wilson feels safe because he has enough followers listening to what he has to
say. He feels if the Committee come after him it will only make him a martyr
and belief in his campaign to expose them would only grow stronger. Skypoint
was going to be the tallest building in the city but back then it was only half
built (nice to see the audios blowing kisses to what BBC Books did with the
series). When Wilson admits that he made it all up I deflated like a saggy
balloon...the idea of the Committee and it's insidious tendrils reaching out
into society and shaping the world was such an exciting idea. It felt
like we had a permanent threat for Torchwood to butt heads with and bring down
at last. So much of the show was the regulars self-destructing, being the
threat themselves. They regulars were at their best when they had a genuine
threat to try and tackle (The Stolen Earth, Children of Earth). If he just made
it all up then how could he get so much of it right? Of course it had to be
Kate that was feeding him the truth about the Conspiracy because she is member
of the organisation. Obvious in hindsight but really well played out in this
story. Kate is Wilson's adopted daughter, one of the Committee in deep cover
for all these years, from childhood. Many planets fell to the Committee across
the galaxy and (surprise surprise) Jack was involved with them at some point.
He really does get about, doesn't he? He told the Committee that Earth was a
barren wasteland, trying to keep them away. The big question on everybody's
lips is why the Committee would want to find themselves exposed, why they would
work so hard to make it happen. Is the Committee in every government, ever
boardroom, every TV screen? How do we recognise them? What is their ultimate
goal?
Audio Landscape: People chattering, applause, a hanging
rope, sirens, telephones ringing, strobe lighting, cocking a gun, a ticking
gun, birdsong, cafe atmosphere, Jack bursting through a door (why can't he just
knock?), being slapped, laser fire in civil war, battle cries, gasping from
water, sirens.
Musical Cues: A gorgeous mutation of the TV theme for audio,
taking out the ohmyGodI'mgoingtohaveaheartattack nature of the theme but
maintaining it's identity and bombastic nature. Exciting but not so over the
top that it screams of trying to make an impact. I think the recognisable TV
Torchwood theme would make my ears bleed on audio. Thumbs up to all concerned,
it certainly got me geared up for the story ahead.
Isn't It Odd: I really don't have very much to complain
about, which feels like something of an anathema with Torchwood.
Standout Scene: Sam hanging himself on Skypoint is far more
graphic than I am used to on audio. That is my own doing, I have only really
explored Big Finish's Doctor Who ranges which is for a family friendly
audience.
Result: 'and I am coming for them...' This is my
first exposure to Torchwood on audio although I realise that BBC Books have
quite a history with the series. I cannot think of a better idea than handing a
series that has the ability to dive bomb into sheer ineptitude to Scott
Handcock and James Goss. The former is responsible for some of the most
economically told and adult material Big Finish have ever released and the
blame for some of the most gripping and thought audio dramas can be laid at the
door of the latter. Giving them Torchwood seems like a perfect fit, I can
imagine them toning down it's excesses whilst still staying true to the show we
know and love and embracing it's quirkiness and willingness to experiment. I
always found Russell T Davies did the majority of his best work when he was
forced to rein in his love of sex, swearing and intense domestic melodrama
(Doctor Who and Sarah Jane) because it forced him to be more creative instead.
Torchwood allowed him to indulge his excesses and they were such extremes at
time the show fell flat on it's face. Once he realised what the show could be
without the tremendous torrent of abuse and sperm it transformed into something
rather magical...and that is what the writers of this audio series need to
focus on. Parts of series two, Children of Earth and the first half of Miracle
Day contained some of the finest material to have been shipped out of BBC
Wales. The Conspiracy turns out to be a remarkably robust first outing for
Torchwood, a tale that manages to be told economically about a few characters
with some lovely twists and turns but with far reaching consequences for both
the range and the world. It introduces the concept of the Committee and has a
great deal of fun with it, a sinister organisation and a conspiracy nuts wet
dream. Wilson is a great character, well written and perfectly played by John
Sessions and he plays beautifully against John Barrowman who seems much more
convincing and comfortable on audio than he ever did on TV. I love the fact that
this story focuses on the nuts and bolts of audio drama, a small but riveting
drama amongst a four characters and an interesting story. Torchwood the TV
series lead me to believe that it could only be played to extremes and I was
expecting an overpowering soundtrack, the death cries of thousands of extras
and at least one gratuitous bit of humping (just imagine that on audio?).
Laying seeds for the future, telling a gripping story and using it's chosen
Torchwood member very well indeed, I felt like applauding at the end. If the
entire range reaches this sort of quality I could be in for a grand old time: 9/10
I'm not sure Big Finish's main range is exactly family friendly *cough* Jubilee *cough* Torchwood just comes with added swearing.
ReplyDeleteOther than that, yay! You're reviewing these! And yes I loved this one too! (Although not as much as most of the later installments)
Great review Joe. I'm so glad Big Finish have got the rights to this, the range has so far been excellent. I was just wondering what you think of the new companion Bill/asBill?
ReplyDeleteAw, fab! Now you're reviewing Torchwood! I was wondering where you went ;)
ReplyDeleteI would very much like to read your review of And You Will Obey Me, and as a second thought, maybe Hounded?
I find a pity Joe stopped reviewing Jago and Litefoot
ReplyDelete