Teeth and Curls: He wont hear of anybody dismantling K.9. He
tries to convince that Romana is the expert and that he just follows her
about...whilst we know this is not entirely accurate when you watch stories
such as Horns of Nimon you have to agree in this season it does start to have a
ring of truth about it. There were always moments of drama in season 17,
moments when the Doctor's facetiousness stripped away and he brought him the
seriousness of the situation. When he calls Emberey a blind, cowardly fool you
genuinely believe that the Doctor is dealing with a truly abominable man. Tom
Baker always makes these moments count. And when it comes to condemning the
other side for acts of murder he is just as succinct. If the Doctor is so
against the idea (which he very much is) then it must be very possible to
rewrite history and forge a new timeline. Baker is as venomous as Hartnell when
delivering the same kind of speech as that in The Aztecs. Why when trying to
escape to the public announcements about how a prisoner on the run do they
never mention how strikingly handsome he is? Perhaps there is something to the
legend of the Doctor if he is to end the war that inspired his reputation.
Noblest of them All: Romana doesn't appreciate being bowed
and scraped and fawned at...which is a sign of a strong character.
Standout Performance: Try and get your head around this
concept - past and future factions debating the rights and wrongs of fighting
against one another. This mind bending idea is made all the more palatable when
it brought to life by actors with the skill of Simon Rouse and Tom Chadbon.
They really sell the material, there is a palpable feeling of hatred between
the two sides of this war. Which is deliciously screwy when you think they are
descendants and antecedents of one another.
Sparkling Dialogue: 'We have not harmed a single living soul
from your time!' 'Only because you daren't!' We you are talking about your
ancestors, those words take on real significance.
'We are the product of your decisions, your short-sightness,
your mistakes, your greed!'
'If you want to solve this worlds problems then take
responsibility for them! Stop blaming your ancestors and start learning from
them!' - a valuable lesson for all of us.
'You can't undo the mistakes of the past, you can only avoid
repeating them.'
Great Ideas: Poor old K.9, only he would hang around for
over a millennia and continue to follow the instructions of the Doctor. He
really is a Time Lord's best friend. The story lends itself to environmental
concerns, which feels very Douglas Adams. Things start to get very wibbly
wobbly in the second half - the Doctor realises that Emberey's great discovery
is what allows them to eventually travel in time, that if it wasn't for him
that there would be no war. Rather wonderfully because the story is set in two
time zones we can enjoy the Doctor's tinkering in the past and K.9 recounting
the events in the future, thus skipping over the boring bits and getting
straight to the juicy stuff. K.9 is such a tease, he fails to mention that the
Doctor is back in future because getting to that point makes a good story. As I
mentioned in The Paradox Planet, the two factions in this war have caused the
very thing that they hate about their past and future counterparts. The future
faction travelled back in time and kidnapped all the endangered animals and
caused them to become extinct. And if it wasn't for the future faction sending
their Chronauts back in time to steal the crystals, the people from era 14
would have been able to use them as a power source instead of fossil fuels.
What is the greatest weapon you could think of to exploit during a temporal
war...the Doctor perhaps? The universe doesn't like self-negating time
paradoxes, the Doctor knows that from experience. Perhaps the participants in
this war have been gorging themselves on too many Doctor Who stories - they
seem to recognise that most of these adventures end by going up in a big bang.
If era 24 had never declared war on era 14 they could have negotiated with them
to give them the xenox crystals and the animals. It's an old moral (and season
seventeen is laden with messages from the hideous blobs not always being
threatening, fancy named drugs being bad news and never look a gift bull in the
mouth) but stop fighting and start talking is one that the human race needs to
learn over and over again. I loved how K.9's 1000 year reputation is dealt with
at the last minute, leaving a final cute little twist to bow out on.
Audio Landscape: Circuits shorting out, fizzing and crackling,
dripping, impulse setting one, the humming time machine, alarms, chanting,
K.9's grinding engine, nose blaster, footsteps on gravel, crackling fire, time
jumps, ticking bombs, birds shrieking.
Standout Scene: After Emberey discovered time travel he went
missing and presumed dead and the people of the future never quite understood
where he went. It turns out he went to the future where he was subsequently
killed. There is something very neat about a story that poses a mystery like
that that spans a thousand years and answers it with such murderous flair
within seconds. That's cracking Jonny Morris plotting for you.
Result: 'Do you want to know who set this planet on a
course of self destruction?' 'Yes, I want to know' 'Then look in the mirror!' More than any other story in his run so far
I was extremely impressed with Tom Baker's performance in this story. He's
never given a poor performance but there are times when he is characterised as
such that it feels more like The Tom Baker Show than Doctor Who. Morris
characterises him beautifully in The Legacy of Death, giving him plenty to rail
against (and you can hear Baker gnashing those teeth as he takes on both sides
in this temporal war) whilst maintaining his sense of humour appropriate to the
season. I was genuinely taken aback at how good he was here, which suggests to
me that a fair amount of his material previous to this story in the 4DAs has
been a beneath him as an actor. Strap yourselves in and prepare yourselves for
a complicated ride in The Legacy of Death but never fear, as long as you engage
your brain there is a huge amount of reward to be found in the conclusion to
this temporal jigsaw puzzle. Don't expect a nice, easy linear ride but do
expect some clever twists and plenty of action. Morris is too smart to leave
any threads hanging and by the time the story is over he crosses all of his ts
and dots all of his is although you might need several listens to get your head
around everything. There's a strong message about talking and not fighting and
accepting the mistakes from the past and learning from them but it doesn't
hammer them home, instead it uses creative ideas to slip them into the
narrative. That's very season seventeen. The first half was more entertaining
but the second half was more dramatic and for Tom Baker's riveting performance
opportunities I felt extremely satisfied with that shift in tone. If only all
the 4DAs could be four episodes long: 8/10
3 comments:
Whew! An 8 out of 10. Solid stuff. I was worried that, like many of the FDA two-parters, the second story would fail miserably. Now it seems that I was wrong! Great review as always, Joe. I'll look forward to Legacy of Death.
Morris is a genius in temporal shenanigans. This story, I needed to listen to it twice to truly appreciate all the twists and turns. Great stuff
The JNT era is coming for the Doctor, so he tries to heroically self-sacrifice to avoid dealing with Adrics and Tegans in his next incarnation
Post a Comment